Advertisement

Local Politics: City Council questions Ginther on planned encampment sweep 

The city intends to destroy a 60-person homeless encampment in Heer Park come December.

Photo by Jules Roscoe

Four members of City Council questioned Mayor Andrew Ginther’s administration in a hearing Monday on its planned sweep of a 60-person homeless encampment in the South Side in order to make room for a new entertainment complex development. 

On Nov. 10, the city of Columbus gave homeless residents at Heer Park a notice that they would need to vacate the area by Dec. 1. This led activists, community medical providers, and even councilmembers to raise serious concerns about how the sweep had been planned. Sweeps are incredibly difficult to live through and do not solve homelessness issues on a larger scale; but these concerns were raised in part because the city had not provided sufficient support for moving the residents into housing, as opposed to just shifting them around the city. 

“These are the hardest of the hardest to place,” council president Shannon Hardin said. “It is one thing to say that encampment needs to leave. It is a whole ’nother thing to say that people need to leave when there is not an actual place for folks to go.”

A donation powers the future of local, independent news in Columbus.

Support Matter News

Emily Myers, founder of community mutual aid group Heer to Serve, which serves the Heer Park encampment, told Matter News at a rally in front of City Hall ahead of the meeting that the camp has been around to some degree for at least six years. In 2022, the city performed a sweep of Heer Park that evicted roughly a dozen people. 

“Those folks moved over onto property nearby and then got evicted off that, again and again and again,” Myers said. “And so this camp where it’s currently at, on these five parcels, has been the kind-of catch-all for the people that get evicted in this area. So this never had to be this large. This is why I say we are basically moving the problem down the road, because now the road has run out, and we’re here.  We are demanding that they stop these camp evictions until we have housing for everybody that’s living on the land, because otherwise we’re just pushing the problem further and further down the road.”

At the rally, a number of residents from the encampment came to speak with community members, activists, and two council members – Melissa Green and Lourdes Barroso de Padilla – about their experiences. Organizers served hot soup and encouraged people to make friends and get to know one another. When time came to move into City Hall for the meeting, the majority of encampment residents couldn’t enter the building because they didn’t have government-issued IDs, owing in part to not having a permanent address. 

The opinions of the speakers at the meeting were almost evenly split: of the nine Columbus residents who gave testimony, four supported going forward with the sweep and five were against it. The packed crowd, however, showed definitive support for those speaking against the sweeps, frequently cheering loudly for them or interjecting and booing the pro-sweep speakers, as well as Columbus’ Director of Development, Hannah Jones. 

Jones said that the development department had been doing outreach in the camp for the past three years, and had been waiting to issue a formal notice to vacate until it had a firm timeline from the Rambling House developer on when it would complete the acquisition of the property. (The South Side property is being purchased by Rambling House Soda founders John and Jen Lynch and has no connection to the Old North music venue Rambling House, which re-opened last November under new ownership.)

But the four council members who participated in the discussion, including Green, Barroso de Padilla, Hardin, and chair of the housing committee Tiara Ross, expressed skepticism that the city had properly done its job. 

“Director Jones, that is just not my experience,” Green said in response. “We had a conversation in September, where you adamantly stated to me that there was no plans for any abatement activity at this location. … I just don’t understand why we could not have been more clear months prior, when the weather would have been thus that, if it was something we had to do, we could have supported individuals.”

Jones argued that the city had chosen to run the sweep now to parallel with the Community Shelter Board opening its winter warming centers. “If this remediation were to occur in the spring, we would have the same conversation, but without the ability to offer any alternate shelter options,” she said. 

But multiple speakers, as well as people in the crowd, argued that winter warming centers aren’t a viable alternate shelter option. 

“Warming stations are not a long-term solution,” Myers said. “They’re not even a temporary solution for most people. We cannot access them. We are maxing out capacity and we’re already at lowered capacity from last year with these huge increases [in homelessness]. So, we can’t use warming stations. We can’t use shelters. People don’t make enough money to afford apartments. And now they’re told that the only place that they have gotten to call home, and the only community that they have to build and have been engaged with, is now being swept away with no options for them.”

Multiple people at the meeting also said that winter is the most dangerous time to run an encampment sweep. 

“ Winter is the deadliest time for people living on the streets and living in the woods,” Willow Cox, a third-year medical student at Ohio State and co-president of the school’s street medicine clinic, told Matter News at the rally ahead of the meeting. “The injuries we see from the winter, I mean, it’s frostbite, it’s limb amputations, but also, people start making fires to keep themselves warm, so we see a lot of burns. Them moving, losing supplies, to unfamiliar places puts them at higher rates of violence. Ideally, we stop the sweeps and are able to get people the help they need in a much more humane and dignified way. If nothing else, our ask is delaying until spring.”

Green told Matter News at the rally that the City Council doesn’t have control of whether the city decides to do a sweep of the encampment; no decisive action was taken on the encampment at the meeting. 

A big reason there aren’t more housing or shelter options in Columbus is money. Simply put, building and running these kinds of projects – particularly non-congregate shelters, which are most effective at moving people into permanent housing – costs a ton. The city allocated $13 million to the Community Shelter Board, the nonprofit that runs housing projects and the winter warming centers, in May, but even that likely won’t be enough to make significant progress on housing. 

Hardin asked Ross to come back next week with a plan on what potential options for the encampment residents might look like and what financial resources are available to the administration. 

“If we can empower you, we need to know what you need,” Ross said to Jones. “This is not going to happen again. I’m not going to go through another winter. Winter literally comes every year. We know when winter comes every single year. And every single year, we’re running around like chickens with our heads cut off. We cannot do this again. So if that means holding funding until we figure it out, then maybe that’s what it means. We’re getting ready to go into an operating budget season. I would hope that the administration brings to us a budget that meets the moment so that we can adequately plan for 2027, because this absolutely just doesn’t make any sense. I know you’re smarter than this.”